What is the importance of the moment you have an insight? For a scientist, you cherish it when a new idea occurs to you that explains your observations. Suddenly, pieces fit together that were previously just a collection of facts. You know what your next paper will be about, but more importantly, your heart is full of joy because you have understood something. You see clearly now.
Scientists can speak of such moments with almost religious devotion, and they do so for good reason. Indeed, there is a parallel to the experience of conversion, of coming to faith not out of obedience to tradition but because it makes sense. What both experiences share is an encounter with truth, in a specific moment, one that may mark our lives forever. Now we are committed to the pursuit of this truth.
Having insights is not just a change in knowledge. It is an event in life that may change its direction. Because life is a movement in time, such a change in direction becomes part of its meaning; it adds to the full shape of a life and the message it sends. True insights let the meaning of our lives unfold more fully, and let us act more truthfully toward ourselves.
The place of insights in the intellectual life as a development in time is one way our thinking differs from what AI does. The human intellectual life is part of an embodied life. In thinking and understanding, we take responsibility for this embodied life and the way it unfolds in time. This makes human thoughts, once mature and properly formed, also ethical. When a mature adult thinks, it is never just about cold rationality disinterested in good and evil.
This is not to deny that we can act against ethics, against values, against the meaning that our lives are meant to have. Nevertheless, mature thought without awareness of ethics is impossible. We never hold just a body of knowledge in which we seek to make new connections. Instead, we see its meaning, and this meaning calls us to a way of acting. We may oppose the call and learn to ignore it. But we can’t pretend that it is not there.
AI maps a body of knowledge and finds new connections in it, and this makes it a tool that can lead us to insights. But in contrast to AI, the human intellect is not just an algorithmic structure that reflects knowledge in an abstract way. The human intellect is meant to join knowledge to ethics in the pursuit of the true, good, and beautiful, and so, finally, to the contemplation of God. AI is the next step in our ingenuity to make larger bodies of knowledge available for us to find him.

